Our Mission

The Preservation League of Staten Island (PLSI) works for the conservation and continued vitality of Staten Island's historic resources. The League was founded in 1977 by a group of community-minded citizens concerned about Staten Island's vanishing historic environment. We sponsor programs about the recognition, care and restoration of historic properties. We have given neighborhood and historic house tours and we confer annual awards for outstanding preservation work. Landmark designation for significant sites is a priority.

Monday, November 15, 2010

Action Alert No. 2: Letter of Concerned Citizens Re: The Fate of the Abraham Manee Homestead

To All of Our Members and Concerned Preservationists:

We will be sending out frequent Preservation Action Alerts for structures that are deemed to be in danger of demolition /alteration.

Preservation Action Alert No 2:   Letter of Concerned Citizens Re: The Fate of the Abraham Manee Homestead:

Neighborhood: Princes Bay
Building use type: Single Family
Condition: Poor
Architect/Builder: Year built: 1670s0/1820
Style: Dutch Colonial
Predominant materials: Stone
NYC Designation Status: Landmark
National Designation Status:
Lot width: 144
Lot depth: 168
Building width: 30
Building depth: 25
Zoning: R3-2


The Manee-Seguine Homestead is named for its early 18th century owner, Abraham Manee, and for the Seguine Family that bought the property in the 1780s. According to the Landmarks Preservation Commission’s designation report, the history of the house may extend back to the construction of a one-room dwelling by Paulus Regrenier in the late 17th century. Its complex building history includes a rubble-stone addition in the early 18th century and other additions in the 19th century.

Located on Prince’s Bay near the southern tip of Staten Island, in a waterfront community. Across the street from it is a small marina, as well as the elegant Seguine House, an 1837 Greek Revival mansion. This context, however, is rapidly changing as newly-constructed townhouses are being built on any available vacant land.

The origins of this house extend back to the construction of a one-room dwelling in the late 17th century. A major rubble stone addition was completed early in the 18th century by Abraham Manee. Subsequent additions in the early 19th century were made by the Seguine family, a prominent and influential group on Staten Island.

This City landmark, which is privately-owned, fell into disrepair over the past decade. On 10/28/03, its owners received the approval of the Landmarks Preservation Commission (LPC) to build four townhouses on the site, thereby generating sufficient funds to restore the landmark to suitable standards. The LPC granted the applicants a Certificate of Appropriateness, approving the proposal. This project has been delayed by litigation over a contract dispute which has recently been resolved. 
 
The Landmarks Conservancy is hopeful that the Manee-Seguine Homestead will soon be saved and can be removed from the endangered buildings watch list.


We need your help in sending Letters to the Landmarks Preservation Commission of NYC (LPC). Letters should be emailed to 

rtierney@lpc.nyc.gov 

or mailed to 

Mailing address:
Robert Tierney
Landmarks Preservation Commission
Municipal Building
1 Centre Street, 9th Floor
New York, NY 10007

Preservation Action Alert No 2: Letter of Concerned Citizens Re: The Fate of the Abraham Manee Homestead

Save the S.I. Castle



Community Demands Preservation of 120 year Castle-like Structure on Staten Island.
Vacant for 31 years!

Contact: Angela D’Aiuto,
Chair, Save the S.I. Castle Committee of the
Preservation League of Staten Island
DIRECT: 718-877-7367


Community Demands Preservation of 120 year Castle-like Structure on Staten Island.
Vacant for 31 years!

WHERE:   100 Castleton Avenue, corner of Castleton Avenue and Oxford Avenue and Cebra Ave- New Brighton, Staten Island.


Save the S.I. Castle Committee is made up of residents, business and professionals whom advocate for the following:
· Preserve the Castle-like building– It is a community anchor.
· Secure the S.I. Castle by ‘shoring up’ the building to ensure the building's re-use and safety of the community.
· Ensure community involvement in the future development of the site with multi-use plan for the site
 This structure was built in 1890 and is the first volunatary hospital on Staten Island. It was vacated in 1979 and condos were planned for the site. Unfortunately, the condo development was never completed and thousands of dollars of tax liens accumulated. The site is managed by HPD and the diposition of the property will be decided in court.

The Save the S.I. Castle Committee is committed to the preservation of the Castle-like structure and the adaptive reuse of the 6 acre site in New Brighton. members have worked with past and current elected officials to advocate for the preservation of the historic building. The entire site is 6 acres and offers opportunities for redevelopment, but it must include the reuse of this community landmark, a community anchor for three intersection communities of New Brighton, Tompkinsville and Silver Lake. The community must continue to be involved with future plans for this site.



The Save the S.I. Castle Committee advocate a 'multi-use' approach for the redevelopment of the site. There is a need for housing, school and community services,all of which can be housed at the six acre site.

Tuesday, November 9, 2010

SAVE THE S.I. CASTLE RALLY - Sunday, Nov. 21st at 2p.m.

SAVE the DATE!

Where: Across the street from the site at the Corner of Castleton Avenue and Oxford Avenue, New Brighton


When: Sunday, Nov. 21st 2 to 3p.m.

Why: The S.I. Castle, formerly S.R. Smith Infirmary and S.I. Hospital is a 120 year old Neo-Medieval style building and should be Landmarked and Re-used for the benefit of the community.

Join us and show your support.

Warm Apple Cider will be served!

Bring a sign to show your support! bring a friend and spread the word! Join the planning committee at sicastle@verizon.net or 718-877-7367.

This event is sponsored by Preservation League of Staten Island.

Monday, November 8, 2010

Action Alert No. 1: Nomination Letter of Support for 66 SWAN STREET

To All of Our Members and Concerned Preservationists:

We will be sending out frequent Preservation Action Alerts for structures that are deemed to be in danger of demolition /alteration.

We need your help in sending Nomination Letters to the Landmarks Preservation Commission of NYC (LPC). Letters should be emaiedl to 

rtierney@lpc.nyc.gov 

or mailed to 

Mailing address:
Robert Tierney
Landmarks Preservation Commission
Municipal Building
1 Centre Street, 9th Floor
New York, NY 10007

Preservation Action Alert No 1: 66 SWAN STREET

This wonderful structure was built in 1902 to house the horses used for the newly consolidated City street sweeping operations on Staten Island. 
66 Swan Street, currently used by the NYC Dept of Sanitation for equipement storage, represents one of the last stables of its kind on Staten Island. Very worthy of preservation!




Thursday, November 4, 2010

St. Austin's Place and Bard Avenue Historic Home Tour of West Brighton & Livingston: This Sunday, November 7, from 1:00 -5:00 pm.

Sign up now, with Pay Pal or Credit Card for one of the best house tours in New York City!  Staten Island is a borough of historic villages.  With this house tour, thePreservation League of Staten Island offers a visit inside six of the most interesting houses in West Brighton and Livingston.

Enjoy the Charm of St. Austins Place:
with homes in the shingle and colonial revival style designed by Stanford White, of the renowned NY Architectural firm, McKim, Meade and White.

Expereince the grandier of Bard Avenue and variety of home styles:
·  the former home of Essayist George William Curtis under restoration by its current owners.
- Italiante style home- part of the orginal development by Dr. Samuel Elliot.
- Exterior of 'Soon to be landmarked' brownstone Villa- Garner Mansion.
· Charming Stone cottage formerly the Kissel Gatehouse on Bard Ave.
· Creatively converted stable on Henderson Avenue.

St. Mary's Episocal Church- It's American Gothic design will delight you!

$30.00 tour fee on the day of the tour, $25.00 if you preregister below with your credit card or Pay Pal.

There will be an additional Guided Walking tour of the neighborhood focusing on  Garner Mansion and neighborhood architectural history. We will start at 3pm in the Cloister of St. Mary's Church and walk by homes not open to the public on Bard and Henderson, ending back at at the church for refreshments around 4pm.
The suggested donation for the walking tour is an additional $10.00. See Below


The tour begins at 14 St. Austin's Place between Davis and Bard Avenues. Registration starts here at 12:30 pm.

The tour ends with refreshments at St. Mary's Episcopal Church, 347 Davis Avenue at Castleton Avenue.